K-ON!: anime review

k-on01k-on03
Title: K-On!
Genre: comedy, drama, musical
Released date: April 3, 2009 – June 26, 2009
Episode: 13
Director: Naoko Yamada
Animated by: Kyoto Animation
Comment: K-On! is the story of four high school girls, Yui, Mio, Mugi and Ritsu who form the light music club. There isn’t much of the plot to describe since there isn’t one. The show depends mostly on characters and small familiar events that occur in everyday life such as doing club activity, going on vacation or throwing a Christmas party. It is certainly fun watching K-On! but I doubt I will gain anything else from it.

K-On! is generally light in tone and full of sense of humor. The use of chibi character and surreal imaging really helps. There are plenty of small details that are artfully presented that will definitely put smiles on the viewers’ faces. The characterization for the four main characters is, in my opinion, the greatest achievement of the show. Without there unique personalities and their interaction, K-On! would be utterly dull. Sawako sensei is exceptionally funny; I can’t stop laughing in all her scenes (especially the scene that she goes berserk, rushing to the music room to cover the embarrassing evidence of her wild past). Another notable thing about this anime is that it always stays close to familiar events that most people must have experienced before. As the result, the show is accessible and appealing to most people, not just anime fans.

k-on06

But from the opposite point of view, without the humor, the anime crashed and burned because it has nothing else to offer. The story progresses very slowly and some episode lacks the storyline completely. For example, the fourth episode in which the girls have a training camp presents nothing that matters at all. There’s just the girls playing around the beach and the campfire and somehow just before they leave, they miraculously improve their performance. This point leads to another thing that disturbs me. For the most part of the show, I only hear about the light music club’s ultimate goal of playing for the school festival or performing at the Budokan but all they do is fooling around, teasing with each other or eating cakes. This is not what one should do to achieve one’s dream. They are supposed to work a little harder in order to really improve their performance, not to mention about being professional musician. Mugi’s rich family is another tool to provide easy solution to every problem the girls has to face like when Mugi helps Yui buy the expensive guitar she cannot afford. Life is not that easy but K-On! may lead the viewers to think otherwise. I think this is the biggest mistake for K-On!

Speaking of Yui, she is cute and funny but I cannot help feeling that she truly is uninspired, unmotivated, dependent and almost good-for-nothing. She is the kind of girl that is fun to watch but hard to deal with. If she were my friend, I’d have been miserable because I’d have to drag her along everywhere and help her do everything.

K-On! never takes itself seriously so it severely lacks substance, not to mention character development or creative ideas. Nevertheless, it succeeds on one aspect which, for many people, may be the most important; it is fun to watch. In my opinion, the show is like candy. It tastes nice but cannot fill the stomach. It’s sad that despite all the laughter the show gave me, I just cannot rate it any higher.
Rating: C

Advertisements

7 responses to “K-ON!: anime review

  1. While I disagree with the overall score of the show, the aspects that were listed as negatives were understandable. This genre of anime though isn’t that common for anime fans, and it may be a bit hard to comprehend a not so coherent and plot-line. But it is what it is. Still a good review nonetheless.

    -Raito

    • Umm, while reviewing K-On!, there were more than once that I wondered if I was too serious about it. The negative thoughts kept appearing in my mind. Maybe the anime somehow related to my certain personal experience (I use to play piano and it wasn’t easy). Well, anyway, big thanks for the compliment and your opinion.

  2. >>Umm, while reviewing K-On!, there were more than once that I wondered if I was too serious about it.
    Yeah, you can tell:
    >Life is not that easy but K-On! may lead the viewers to think otherwise.
    This line made me LOL. Not everyone uses anime as the basis for their way of living. A solid review nonetheless.

  3. It seems that many people either love this series completely or hate it to its core. I like K-On! as it allows me to kills time enjoyably, but I don’t absolutely love it.
    I think that’s a pretty good and fair review. It may have little substance to offer, but as you pointed out, it really is fun to watch.

  4. Pingback: Recalling 2009: My most memorable anime moments « Canne's anime review blog

  5. Well in the end how much you’ll like K-ON (as well several other similar shows) largely boils down to the question “how much do you like watching cute girls do cute things”.

    Of course there’s other elements in the show that you can like or dislike but I would say that’s still the primary factor. As to my own opinion on the show I found it to be fairly enjoyable, not one of my favorites but still worth watching.

    • I have something to confess. After a few episode into the second season and all, my overall impression on this show has changed quite a lot, in a positive way. :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s